Local market / Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

Aaron’s Acres turns a former Millersville church into a permanent campus

The nonprofit’s move to 121 Walnut Hill Road shows how a former assembly property can become a specialized community campus when zoning, accessibility, parking and phased improvements are addressed together.

Aaron’s Acres has converted a former church property at 121 Walnut Hill Road in Millersville into its first permanent campus. The nonprofit celebrated the purchase on October 26, 2026, and the 12,000-square-foot building is already hosting programs while a larger improvement plan moves forward. The reported project budget is $6.6 million, including an accessible pool planned for a later phase. [1]

That is a meaningful Lancaster County commercial real estate story because the property was not simply an empty building waiting for a new sign. It was an existing assembly property being adapted for a more specialized mix of recreation, education, administration and family support.

The zoning record shows what the reuse required

Before settlement, Aaron’s Acres sought a use variance from Manor Township for a commercial daycare or school, administrative offices and a summer camp on the 3.9-acre property. The parcel is in the Medium Density Residential district. Township minutes describe planned restroom accessibility upgrades, kitchen and storage work, minor office changes, a future pool and daytime programming. They also record 96 parking spaces and a peak summer-camp scenario that could fill the lot. The board approved the requested use unanimously in August 2025. [2]

Those details matter more than the former church label. A building can appear physically compatible with a community use and still require a specific approval path, a documented operating plan and a realistic answer for peak parking.

The acquired property did not match the first wish list exactly

In December 2022, Aaron’s Acres publicly described an ideal search of six to eight acres, roughly 14,000 to 16,000 square feet, a pool or room to build one, Lancaster County highway access and a $3 million to $3.5 million project budget. [3]

The completed search produced a 3.9-acre site and a reported 12,000-square-foot building. The broader project is now reported at $6.6 million. [1][2] That comparison is useful, but it should not be read as a shortfall. It shows how real property searches evolve once an organization weighs location, existing layout, approvals, construction scope, fundraising capacity and the cost of waiting.

The former owner’s move also created the opportunity. Grace Baptist Church sold the Walnut Hill Road property to Aaron’s Acres after buying a larger building on Bender Road. The church had considered expanding at Walnut Hill Road but found that option expensive and dependent on public water and sewer. [4] One organization’s constrained property became another organization’s workable platform.

Why this building type can translate well

Former churches and other assembly buildings can offer features that are expensive to create from scratch:

  1. A large central room that can support recreation, events or group programming.
  2. Secondary rooms that can become classrooms, offices or support spaces.
  3. A kitchen and gathering areas that can be upgraded instead of started from zero.
  4. Parking designed for concentrated arrival times.
  5. A familiar community location rather than a remote industrial address.

The fit is not automatic. Accessibility, restrooms, circulation, fire and life-safety systems, outdoor activity, neighborhood impacts and the permitted use all need independent review. Aaron’s Acres addressed those questions through a public approval process and a phased plan rather than treating the existing building as finished space. [2]

Four practical lessons for Lancaster property searches

First, separate the operating requirements from the first property specification. Acreage and square footage matter, but so do access, room configuration, parking, surrounding uses and the ability to phase improvements.

Second, test the use before committing to the building. The Manor Township record shows why zoning and operating details belong in due diligence, not after closing.

Third, model peak conditions rather than average conditions. Six regular office users and a full summer program place very different demands on the same parking lot. [2]

Fourth, compare adaptive reuse with both new construction and continued leasing. Aaron’s Acres had spent years using leased or borrowed program locations. A permanent campus can reduce scheduling friction and support purpose-built improvements, but it also concentrates capital needs into one property. [1][3]

For Lancaster County owners and occupants, the broader takeaway is simple: the best reuse candidate is not necessarily the building that matches every line of the original wish list. It is the property whose location, approvals, physical layout and improvement plan can support the operation for years.

Sources & further reading

How does this affect your property?

Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.

Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space

Talk with Zach