Amore opens an Italian kitchen and bar in Mount Joy’s former Watering Trough
The new restaurant at 905 West Main Street combines Italian cooking, a bar and celebration dining in a longtime gathering place. Current hours and the property’s history help explain the new concept.
Amore Traditional Italian Kitchen & Bar is open at 905 West Main Street in Mount Joy, giving the former Watering Trough building a new Italian restaurant concept. The Lancaster Local reported on October 12 that regular hours began Monday, October 5, following a soft-launch weekend. The restaurant’s own website now includes a thank-you message for its first week and lists regular opening hours. [1][2][3]
As checked October 18, Amore posts hours of 11 a.m. to 10 p.m., Wednesday through Monday, with Tuesdays closed. Visitors should check the restaurant’s current information before making a special trip. The Mount Joy Area Chamber also lists the business at the same West Main Street address. [2][4]
A familiar gathering place with a new menu
Amore describes a kitchen focused on house-made pasta, wood-fired entrées and family recipes, alongside cocktails and an Italian-focused wine list. Its website also presents an intimate dining room for celebrations as part of the concept. [1]
The building gives that introduction a local connection. According to the restaurant’s published history, records trace the property’s tavern use to 1818, in the village then known as Springville. Amore says an original spring-fed horse trough remains out front and identifies The Watering Trough as the building’s most recent prior name. [1]
The property question: can different visits work together?
Amore’s combination of food, bar service and celebrations illustrates a useful planning question for hospitality operators: what happens when different reasons for visiting overlap?
The following is planning analysis, not a description of Amore’s floor plan or private operating arrangements.
Imagine a restaurant serving ordinary dinner reservations while a celebration group arrives. The property needs to support both experiences. The group’s arrival, waiting area and service needs should not prevent other guests from reaching their tables or staff from moving through the dining room.
A prospective operator can test that scenario on a plan before committing to a space. Mark the entrance, waiting area, bar, dining tables, kitchen routes and restrooms. Then ask where a group would gather and how service would continue around it. Staffing, acoustics and the reservation policy belong in the same discussion.
A building’s history can help introduce a restaurant. Its day-to-day layout still has to support the way people will use it.
For Mount Joy diners, the immediate news is straightforward: a new Italian kitchen and bar has begun regular service at a familiar address. For commercial property owners and restaurant operators, the useful lesson is to evaluate a concept by its overlapping activities—not simply its total seat count.
Sources
[1] Amore, official website and building-history account, accessed October 18, 2026. https://amoreeats.com/
[2] Amore, “Contact Us,” current address and hours, accessed October 18, 2026. https://amoreeats.com/?page_id=14
[3] The Lancaster Local, “A Mount Joy Building Licensed as a Tavern in 1818 Has a New Restaurant,” October 12, 2026; accessed October 18, 2026. https://thelancasterlocal.com/p/a-mount-joy-building-licensed-as-a-tavern-in-1818-has-a-new-restaurant
[4] Mount Joy Area Chamber of Commerce, “Amore Traditional Italian Kitchen & Bar,” current business listing, accessed October 18, 2026. https://mountjoychamber.com/places/amore-traditional-italian-kitchen-bar/
Sources & further reading
- 1. Amore — official restaurant concept and building historyCurrent company page; accessed October 18, 2026
- 2. Amore — current address and opening hoursCurrent company contact page; accessed October 18, 2026
- 3. The Lancaster Local — Mount Joy restaurant opening coveragePublished October 12, 2026; accessed October 18, 2026
- 4. Mount Joy Area Chamber — Amore business listingCurrent business directory; accessed October 18, 2026
How does this affect your property?
Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.
Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space
Talk with Zach