Learn commercial real estate / Lancaster County and Pennsylvania

Commercial lease relocation clauses: define comparable before you sign

A practical guide to defining comparable replacement space, relocation costs, timing, rent adjustments and exit rights before a landlord relocation clause is signed.

A relocation clause can allow a commercial landlord to move a tenant to another suite during the lease term.

For a landlord, that flexibility can help combine spaces, accommodate a larger tenant or reconfigure a property. For a tenant, the same clause can interrupt operations, weaken visibility and create a second buildout.

The solution is not the word “comparable.” It is defining what comparable means before the lease is signed.

This article is general commercial real estate education, not legal advice. Commercial lease rights depend on the signed documents and applicable law. Have qualified Pennsylvania counsel review a proposed clause.

Read the relocation right at the letter-of-intent stage

A commercial leasing guide prepared for small businesses and nonprofits in Philadelphia warns tenants to examine relocation rights carefully. It suggests negotiating notice, a similar or larger location and size, no increase in rent, a termination option, timing limits and a cap on how often relocation can occur. [1]

Those points are easier to negotiate before the full lease is drafted. If the letter of intent says nothing, the first detailed relocation language may appear in the landlord’s lease form after the business has invested time in the site.

Add relocation to the initial business terms:

  1. Is relocation allowed at all?
  2. What event can trigger it?
  3. How much notice is required?
  4. How many times may it occur?
  5. Who selects and approves the replacement space?
  6. Who pays each category of cost?
  7. Can the tenant terminate instead?
  8. Does rent change?

“Comparable” needs a scorecard

A substitute suite with the same square footage can still perform differently.

Define comparable with the features that matter to the actual business:

  1. Building, floor and general location.
  2. Storefront width and customer visibility.
  3. Proximity to entrances, elevators and anchors.
  4. Parking and accessible routes.
  5. Loading, drive-in doors and delivery paths.
  6. Ceiling height and floor capacity.
  7. Utility capacity and building systems.
  8. Signage rights.
  9. Permitted use and required approvals.
  10. Layout efficiency after columns, walls and unusable areas.
  11. Operating hours and customer access.
  12. Condition and quality of improvements.

A retailer may care most about frontage and neighboring tenants. A medical practice may need plumbing, patient privacy and accessible circulation. A contractor may need loading, storage and vehicle access. An office tenant may care about floor, views, elevator bank and conference-room layout.

One definition does not fit every use.

A filed lease shows how detailed the mechanics can be

A publicly filed office lease gave the landlord a right to move the tenant to comparable space within the project at the landlord’s cost. It described comparable finishes and room types, required lease documents to be updated and adjusted rent, the security deposit and the tenant’s share if the rentable area changed. [2]

That is one negotiated lease, not a Pennsylvania standard. It demonstrates the number of moving pieces that a short clause can leave unresolved.

A complete clause may need to address:

  1. The replacement premises.
  2. Delivery condition.
  3. Construction and approval process.
  4. Move date and sequencing.
  5. Rent and additional-rent adjustments.
  6. Security deposit changes.
  7. Sign replacement.
  8. Address and marketing changes.
  9. Damage during the move.
  10. The handoff of the original suite.

Build a real relocation budget

“Landlord pays moving costs” may cover only the truck and movers.

A tenant should identify the full cost list:

  1. Architectural and engineering work.
  2. Permits and inspections.
  3. New walls, finishes and specialty improvements.
  4. Equipment disconnection and reinstallation.
  5. Data cabling, phones and security.
  6. Signs, menus, stationery and address changes.
  7. Inventory handling.
  8. Professional fees.
  9. Duplicate occupancy and utilities.
  10. Business interruption and employee downtime.

Stoel Rives recommends addressing timing, advance notice, location details and costs such as wiring and reprinting business materials. It also suggests considering rent abatement around the move when disruption could be significant. [3]

Thompson Coburn similarly identifies notice, acceptable substitute space, rent adjustment, relocation expense and the events that can trigger the clause as central negotiating points. [4]

The financial schedule should say whether the landlord pays vendors directly, reimburses documented invoices or provides an allowance. It should also set a payment deadline and explain what happens if the actual cost exceeds an estimate.

Control the timing

A move can be more damaging during a business’s busiest period.

Consider negotiating:

  1. A minimum notice period.
  2. Blackout dates during peak season.
  3. No relocation during the opening period.
  4. No relocation near the end of the term.
  5. A limit of one move.
  6. A requirement that the new space be ready before the old space is surrendered.
  7. A defined period for equipment testing and customer transition.
  8. Rent relief if the tenant cannot operate during the move.

The lease should also explain what happens if the replacement space is late. A move date without a delivery standard can leave the tenant paying attention to two spaces while neither is fully operational.

Give the tenant an exit test

If the substitute space fails defined criteria, the tenant may want a right to reject it or terminate the lease.

That decision should not depend on a vague statement that the tenant is dissatisfied. Tie it to measurable conditions, such as:

  1. Minimum or maximum rentable area.
  2. Required building or floor.
  3. Minimum storefront width.
  4. Equal or better access and parking.
  5. Required loading or utility capacity.
  6. Preservation of exclusive-use and signage rights.
  7. Completion by a stated deadline.
  8. No increase in total occupancy cost beyond an agreed formula.

The landlord may want a cure period or a right to offer another suite. The tenant may want reimbursement of unamortized improvements or other negotiated costs if the lease ends. Those are legal and economic terms for the parties and counsel to resolve.

The practical comparison

A useful relocation exhibit can be a two-column table: existing premises and substitute premises.

Compare the same facts for both spaces:

  1. Rentable and usable area.
  2. Base rent and additional rent.
  3. Frontage and signs.
  4. Parking and loading.
  5. Utilities.
  6. Existing improvements.
  7. Required new work.
  8. Delivery date.
  9. Move cost.
  10. Expected downtime.

If the replacement cannot be compared on paper, the word “comparable” is doing too much work.

The question to settle before signing

Ask: “If the landlord moves us in year three, what exact space must be offered, who pays every cost, and can we leave if it does not work?”

That question turns a broad landlord right into an operating plan. A carefully defined relocation clause can preserve property flexibility without making the tenant absorb an undefined second opening.

Sources & further reading

How does this affect your property?

Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.

Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space

Talk with Zach