Learn commercial real estate / Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

Commercial lease signage: secure the right before you fabricate the sign

A practical guide to defining sign locations, landlord approval, municipal permits, visibility, installation costs, maintenance and end-of-term removal before signing a lease.

# Commercial lease signage: secure the right before you fabricate the sign

A business can lease a visible location and still discover that its preferred sign is not permitted by the lease, the landlord’s design rules or the municipality.

Settle the sign package before the lease is signed and before fabrication begins.

For a commercial tenant, “signage allowed” is not specific enough. The lease should identify the type, number, location, size, lighting, approval process, cost, maintenance and end-of-term removal obligations for the signs the business actually needs.

This article is general business education, not legal or code advice. Requirements vary by property and municipality. Have qualified Pennsylvania counsel review the lease and confirm the current approval path with the local authority.

Landlord approval and municipal approval are separate

A landlord can approve a sign design without determining that the municipality will issue a permit. A municipality can issue a permit without giving the tenant a private lease right to install the sign.

The tenant may need both.

The City of Lancaster’s current permit guidance includes a zoning sign application and notes that signs larger than 2.5 square feet require signed and sealed drawings, subject to a limited exception for certain small projecting signs. It also explains that historic-preservation review may apply to exterior work in designated districts.[1]

Manheim Township states that permits are required for both new signs and replacements of existing signs, with one application required for each sign.[2]

Those examples show why a business should not assume that replacing a previous tenant’s panel or reusing an existing cabinet avoids review. Confirm the rule with the municipality responsible for the exact property.

Put the actual sign package in the lease

List every sign the business expects to use:

  1. Storefront or wall sign
  2. Monument or pylon panel
  3. Directory listing
  4. Door and window lettering
  5. Directional or wayfinding sign
  6. Awning or blade sign
  7. Building-top identification
  8. Loading, pickup or customer-parking signs
  9. Temporary grand-opening or event signs
  10. Interior signs visible from outside

For each item, define the location, maximum dimensions, design standard, illumination and approval process.

Commercial-leasing guidance from Moorhead Law recommends addressing the type, design, number and location of tenant signs during lease negotiation. It also identifies storefront, window, monument, pylon and illuminated signs as items a retail tenant may need to discuss before signing.[4]

A site plan or lease exhibit is often clearer than a general sentence. Mark the exact wall, monument panel or directory position. If the sign is important to the deal, ask counsel to make the approved exhibit part of the signed documents.

A real lease example shows how many responsibilities can be hidden in one clause

A publicly filed commercial lease gives one contract example. It permits one exterior sign above the tenant’s doorway and another building sign subject to landlord approval. The clause also requires governmental approvals, places installation and maintenance costs on the tenant, provides for monument-sign identification, and assigns removal costs at the end of the term.[3]

That is one negotiated lease, not a Lancaster market standard and not recommended language.

Its value is showing the number of decisions that can sit behind the word “signage”:

  1. How many signs are allowed
  2. Where they may be installed
  3. What the signs may display
  4. Whether landlord approval may be withheld
  5. Who obtains public approvals
  6. Who pays to design and install
  7. Who supplies electricity
  8. Who maintains the sign
  9. Whether the right transfers after an assignment
  10. Who removes the sign and repairs the surface

A tenant should compare the proposed clause with its operating plan rather than assuming a standard form supports the brand.

Price the complete sign, not only the face

A sign budget may include more than fabrication.

Request estimates for:

  1. Survey and field measurements
  2. Design
  3. Engineering and sealed drawings
  4. Landlord review charges, if permitted by the lease
  5. Municipal applications and fees
  6. Historic or architectural review
  7. Electrical work
  8. Mounting structure and roof or wall protection
  9. Lift or crane access
  10. Traffic control or right-of-way work
  11. Fabrication
  12. Installation
  13. Utility use
  14. Maintenance and cleaning
  15. Future face changes
  16. Removal and building restoration

Confirm whether the quoted price includes permits, wiring, final inspection and patching after removal.

For a monument sign, also ask whether the tenant pays only for its panel or shares the cost of the structure, landscaping, lighting and future redesign.

Test visibility before committing to the location

A sign can satisfy the lease and code while still being difficult for customers to see.

Evaluate the site from the customer’s actual approach:

  1. Which road and direction generate most arrivals?
  2. How long is the sign visible at normal traffic speed?
  3. Do trees, utility poles or other signs block the view?
  4. Is the entrance obvious after the sign is seen?
  5. Can a driver read the message without slowing unexpectedly?
  6. Does the sign remain legible at night and in bad weather?
  7. Is the tenant’s monument panel large enough relative to the other panels?
  8. Can delivery drivers find the correct door?
  9. Does the sign direct pedestrians from shared parking?
  10. Will planned landscaping or another phase of construction change visibility?

Photographs from several approach points can make the lease discussion more concrete. A marked exhibit can also reduce confusion about which sign location was approved.

Coordinate the approval sequence

A practical sequence is:

  1. Identify the required sign types during property tours
  2. Review the zoning district, sign rules and any historic requirements
  3. Obtain the landlord’s sign criteria
  4. Prepare a preliminary concept with dimensions and lighting
  5. Attach the intended locations and rights to the lease
  6. Confirm the public application path
  7. Obtain written landlord design approval
  8. Submit complete permit materials
  9. Fabricate only after required approvals are in place
  10. Install, inspect and retain the permit record
  11. Calendar maintenance and end-of-term removal duties

The lease should also address what happens if the primary sign cannot be approved. Possible business decisions may include revising the design, using another approved location or reconsidering whether the space still works. Counsel should translate the negotiated outcome into the documents.

Plan for changes during the lease

Sign needs can change after a rebrand, expansion, assignment or center renovation.

Ask:

  1. Can the tenant change its trade name or logo?
  2. Does every face change require landlord approval?
  3. Can the landlord relocate a monument panel?
  4. What happens if construction blocks the sign?
  5. Does an assignee inherit the sign right?
  6. Are renewal-period sign rights preserved?
  7. Who pays if the landlord changes the property’s sign program?
  8. Must the tenant remove all mounting hardware at lease end?
  9. What restoration standard applies to masonry, siding or roofing?
  10. Can the landlord remove an unapproved sign and bill the tenant?

Do not wait until a sign fails or the lease ends to find the answer.

The practical lesson

A strong location includes a workable way for customers to identify and enter the business. Treat signage as part of the real estate decision, not a marketing detail that begins after possession.

Before signing, match three things: the sign the business needs, the sign the landlord will permit and the sign the municipality may approve. Then budget the entire life of the sign from drawings and installation through maintenance and removal.

Sources & further reading

How does this affect your property?

Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.

Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space

Talk with Zach