Learn commercial real estate / Lancaster County and Pennsylvania

Commercial lease utilities: direct meter, submeter or pro-rata bill?

“Tenant pays utilities” is not a complete budget. Identify the meter, service area, allocation formula, fees, reconciliation and upgrade responsibility for every utility.

# Commercial lease utilities: direct meter, submeter or pro-rata bill?

A lease saying “tenant pays utilities” does not explain how the bill will be measured.

The premises may have a direct utility meter, a landlord-owned submeter or no dedicated meter at all. Each method can produce a different invoice, different records and a different level of control.

Before comparing two Lancaster commercial spaces, identify the billing method for electricity, gas, water, sewer, heating and cooling separately.

Three common billing methods

1. Direct utility account

A separately metered tenant usually establishes an account with the utility provider and pays the provider directly.

This method gives the tenant a bill tied to the provider’s meter and rate structure. It can also make budgeting easier because the tenant can compare usage across billing periods.

Direct service still leaves questions:

  1. Is the meter dedicated only to the premises?
  2. Are exterior lights, shared equipment or another suite connected?
  3. Who pays connection or upgrade costs?
  4. Is the existing service large enough for the proposed operation?
  5. Who is responsible if the account or meter must be changed?

A direct account measures what passes through that meter. It does not prove that every load behind the meter belongs to one tenant.

2. Landlord submeter

A submeter sits downstream from a utility’s primary meter and measures a portion of the building’s use. The landlord receives the master bill and charges the tenant based on submeter readings and the lease formula.

The U.S. Department of Energy explains that submetering can provide more accurate tenant-space billing than a simple pro-rata allocation. It also cautions that installing permanent submeters has a cost and that different meter types provide different levels of accuracy and capability.[1]

A lease should state:

  1. Which utilities are submetered
  2. Who owns, reads and maintains each meter
  3. How often readings occur
  4. What rate converts usage into dollars
  5. Whether taxes, demand charges or other master-bill items are allocated
  6. Whether meter-reading or administrative fees are added
  7. What happens if the submeter fails
  8. How a tenant may review readings and supporting bills
  9. Whether common-area usage is billed separately
  10. Who pays to install or replace the equipment

A submeter provides data. The lease still determines the price calculation.

3. Pro-rata allocation

When a building has no dedicated meter or submeter, the landlord may allocate a shared bill using square footage or another stated formula.

The American Bar Association’s commercial-leasing guide explains that utilities serving a multitenant property are often allocated by a tenant’s pro-rata share when exact premises-level use cannot be measured efficiently.[2]

A square-footage allocation is simple, but it may not match actual consumption. A low-use office and a high-use production space of the same size could receive the same share if the lease uses only area.

That does not make the method automatically wrong. Shared systems sometimes cannot be measured economically. It does mean the tenant should understand the denominator, the service area and any adjustment for unusual use.

A filed lease shows how several methods can coexist

A commercial lease filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission provides a useful example. It requires the tenant to pay the utility provider directly for separately metered service, pay the landlord for submetered use and pay a proportionate share for utilities that are not separately metered or submetered.[3]

The same lease allows estimated utility charges followed by an annual reconciliation and includes certain meter-reading costs.[3]

That document concerns a negotiated Texas office lease, not Pennsylvania law or a recommended form. Its value is showing that one premises can use several billing methods at once.

For example:

  1. Electricity may be directly metered.
  2. Water may be shared by the building.
  3. Heating or cooling may be included in operating expenses.
  4. After-hours heating or cooling may be separately charged.
  5. Exterior lighting may be part of common-area costs.

“Tenant pays utilities” is too short to describe that structure.

A worked allocation example

Assume a hypothetical multitenant building receives a $48,000 annual electricity bill for an area served by one shared meter.

A tenant occupies 6,000 square feet of the 30,000-square-foot service area.

The tenant’s square-footage share is:

6,000 divided by 30,000 = 20 percent

The allocated annual charge would be:

$48,000 multiplied by 20 percent = $9,600

That equals:

$9,600 divided by 12 months = $800 per month

Now assume a reliable submeter instead shows that the premises used 15 percent of the metered consumption and the lease allocates the bill on that basis.

$48,000 multiplied by 15 percent = $7,200 per year

That equals $600 per month.

The difference is $2,400 per year.

This is an educational example, not a Lancaster utility estimate. A real bill may include common-area loads, taxes, demand-related charges, minimum charges, meter-reading costs or other amounts that require a separate allocation. A submeter percentage also may not map directly to every component of the master bill.

Match the method to the use

DLA Piper’s current United States commercial-lease guide notes that multitenant electricity may be paid directly, measured through submeters or allocated under a landlord’s formula. It also observes that water arrangements often differ by property use, with restaurants and industrial users more likely to be responsible for measured actual use where possible.[4]

That distinction matters in Lancaster flex, warehouse, retail and food spaces.

A business should identify its major loads before touring:

  1. Production machinery
  2. Electric heating
  3. Refrigeration
  4. Commercial cooking
  5. Compressed air
  6. Vehicle charging
  7. Washdown or process water
  8. Extended operating hours
  9. Server or specialized equipment rooms
  10. Outdoor lighting or yard equipment

If the proposed use is much more utility-intensive than neighboring tenants, a direct meter or submeter may provide a clearer allocation. It may also reveal that the existing service needs an expensive upgrade.

Check capacity as well as billing

A low historical utility bill does not prove that a property can support the next tenant.

Request available information about:

  1. Electrical voltage, phase and amperage
  2. Transformer capacity
  3. Gas service
  4. Water-line size and pressure
  5. Sewer capacity
  6. Heating and cooling zones
  7. Existing meters and account numbers
  8. Shared loads behind each meter
  9. Prior usage records
  10. Planned equipment additions

A qualified contractor or engineer may need to confirm actual capacity. The lease should assign the cost and ownership of upgrades, meters, submeters and utility extensions.

Prevent duplicate charges

Utilities can appear as a direct bill, a separate landlord invoice or part of operating expenses.

Create a utility map before signing. For each service, record:

  1. Provider
  2. Meter number
  3. Area served
  4. Billing method
  5. Rate or allocation formula
  6. Common-area component
  7. Administrative or reading fee
  8. Estimate and reconciliation process
  9. Record-review right
  10. Upgrade responsibility

Then compare the utility clause with the operating-expense definition. The ABA guide notes that utility-related charges may be treated as a separate category or included within maintenance and operating costs.[2]

The document should prevent the same cost from being recovered twice.

The practical takeaway

Do not budget utilities from the lease label alone.

Ask for the meter map, recent bills when available and a plain-language explanation of how every utility reaches the premises and reaches the tenant’s invoice. Model the cost using the proposed operation, not the prior occupant’s use.

This article is general commercial real estate education, not legal, engineering, accounting or utility-rate advice. Billing obligations depend on the signed lease, the physical systems and the applicable service arrangements. Pennsylvania counsel and appropriate technical professionals should review the actual property and documents.

Sources & further reading

How does this affect your property?

Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.

Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space

Talk with Zach