Local market / Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

Goodwill plans a 17,000-square-foot Parkview Plaza store in the former JOANN

Goodwill Keystone plans to open a store and donation center at 838 Plaza Boulevard on December 10. The reuse shows why a donation-driven retailer needs receiving, sorting and sales flow—not just an available big box.

Goodwill Keystone plans to open a store and donation center in the former JOANN space at 838 Plaza Boulevard in Parkview Plaza on Thursday, December 10, at 9 a.m. Goodwill’s own page confirms the Parkview Plaza location and a December 2026 opening, while ABC27 reports the exact opening time, a 17,000-square-foot footprint and 25 planned jobs. The location is still planned, not yet open. [1][2]

The real-estate lesson is not simply that a vacant large-format store found another tenant. A combined thrift store and donation center has two connected operations: customers shop the sales floor while donors arrive with unsorted goods that must be received, evaluated, processed and moved into inventory.

A big box with a second front door

Traditional retail site selection often starts with storefront visibility, parking and sales-floor area. Donation retail adds a receiving question: can donors reach a clearly marked drop-off without conflicting with shoppers, delivery trucks or pedestrian routes?

Goodwill’s recruiting material for 838 Plaza Boulevard describes work in donated-goods retail and identifies customer service, merchandise processing, sales and utility functions. It also says parts of the work occur in an open warehouse environment. [4] That does not disclose the final floor plan, but it confirms that the operation extends beyond racks and registers.

For an owner evaluating a similar reuse, the useful circulation map should include:

  1. Shopper entry, carts and checkout.
  2. Donor vehicle approach, unloading and exit.
  3. Merchandise receiving and temporary holding.
  4. Sorting, pricing and processing.
  5. Movement from processing to the sales floor.
  6. Refuse, recycling and rejected-item handling.
  7. Employee parking and service access.

If those routes cross in the wrong places, a large vacancy can still be operationally tight.

Parkview provides scale and an established retail mix

Cedarwood Companies lists Parkview Plaza at 191,882 square feet across 21 storefronts on 25.4 acres. The owner’s current tenant list includes T.J. Maxx, Ollie’s Bargain Outlet, Boot Barn, Crunch Fitness and several value-oriented or service businesses. [3]

That context matters. A 17,000-square-foot reuse represents about 8.9 percent of the center’s listed building area. That percentage is a simple comparison, not a statement about rentable area or economic value:

17,000 divided by 191,882 equals approximately 8.9 percent.

The former JOANN space can keep a meaningful portion of the center active while adding a use that combines repeat shopping with donation trips. The surrounding tenant mix may also support linked errands, but customer behavior should be measured after opening rather than assumed in advance.

Reuse still requires a conversion plan

A former craft store may already offer open floor area, a retail entrance, lighting and parking. Those features can shorten part of the conversion process, but the new use creates different questions.

First, the receiving zone may need overhead-door access, weather protection, cameras, signage and a safe vehicle queue. Second, donated inventory changes continuously, so back-of-house capacity and rapid movement can be more important than fixed merchandising. Third, some donations cannot be sold, which makes waste handling and storage part of the operating plan. Fourth, fire protection, egress, accessibility, occupancy approval and interior work must match the actual layout and use.

The announcement and recruiting activity do not establish which improvements are complete or which approvals remain. Owners and tenants should keep the planned opening separate from construction completion, inspections and certificate timing.

Questions for another large-format reuse

A Lancaster landlord or occupant considering a similar box should ask:

  1. How much area is truly available after receiving, processing, employee and utility rooms?
  2. Can donation, customer and truck traffic operate at the same time?
  3. Does the loading arrangement fit the operator’s carts, pallets and removal schedule?
  4. Is the electrical service adequate for lighting, point-of-sale systems, compactors and processing equipment?
  5. Where will rejected goods, cardboard and trash be held?
  6. Can exterior signs explain both shopping and donation access from the ring road?
  7. Who pays for storefront, dock, paving, security and waste-area changes?
  8. What work must be complete before stocking begins?
  9. What opening-date flexibility exists if an inspection or equipment delivery moves?

Goodwill’s plan is a constructive example of second-generation retail reuse, but it is not proof that every vacant box fits a donation retailer. The best match comes from testing the complete flow of goods, people and vehicles before treating square footage as the answer.

Sources & further reading

How does this affect your property?

Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.

Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space

Talk with Zach