A 5% CAM cap does not necessarily cap your NNN bill at 5%
Expense exclusions, the calculation base and carry-forward rights determine what a CAM cap protects. A worked example shows why the percentage alone is not enough.
A 5 percent cap on common-area maintenance charges does not necessarily mean your total triple-net, or NNN, bill can rise by no more than 5 percent.
The cap may cover only specified operating expenses. Taxes, insurance, utilities or other items may sit outside it. Base rent may have a separate increase. Even within the capped pool, two clauses using the same percentage can produce different bills. [1]
The useful question is not only, “What is the cap?” It is, “What dollars does it cover, and how is the next ceiling calculated?”
First, identify the protected expense pool
The American Bar Association’s operating-expense guide identifies the definition of controllable expenses as a key negotiation point. It discusses categories such as taxes, insurance, utilities and snow removal that parties may treat differently. [1]
There is no substitute for the actual definitions.
Suppose a hypothetical tenant pays $20,000 in capped operating expenses and $15,000 in uncapped taxes and insurance. If capped expenses rise 5 percent while the other charges rise 20 percent:
Capped expenses: $20,000 × 1.05 = $21,000.
Uncapped charges: $15,000 × 1.20 = $18,000.
Combined charges: $39,000, up from $35,000—an increase of about 11.43 percent.
These figures are invented for education, not Lancaster expense forecasts. The example shows why a cap on one pool does not cap the whole bill.
Second, identify the calculation base
Hirschler’s drafting analysis separates caps based on prior-year expenses, straight-line increases from a base year, and increases applied to the prior-year cap itself. It also treats carry-forward and recapture rights as separate drafting issues. [2]
Here is another hypothetical example. Start with a $100,000 controllable-expense pool and a 5 percent limit. Assume year-two actual expenses are only $102,000.
Under a formula based on the prior year’s actual allowable expenses, the year-three ceiling would be:
$102,000 × 1.05 = $107,100.
Under a formula that increases the original ceiling by 5 percent each year regardless of actual spending:
$100,000 × 1.05 × 1.05 = $110,250.
If year-three actual expenses reach $112,000, the second formula allows $3,150 more into the capped pool. A tenant with a constant 10 percent share would see a $315 difference, assuming no other adjustments.
Both calculations are consistent with their stated assumptions. Neither formula should be assigned to a lease merely because it contains the word “cumulative.”
Do not rely on shorthand
Hollander’s published example illustrates language in which the ceiling increases each year regardless of whether actual expenses were below the previous ceiling. [3] That is different from simply limiting growth in actual expenses.
Terms such as cumulative, noncumulative, compounding and noncompounding can be used inconsistently. Ask for a numerical schedule using the proposed clause. Include one low-expense year followed by a sharp increase.
Also ask whether unused room below the cap can be carried forward, whether costs previously blocked by the cap can be recovered later, and whether those rights expire. The signed language should settle those questions.
Keep a cap worksheet with the reconciliation
For each year, record:
- Actual expenses in the defined pool.
- Excluded or separately billed charges.
- The base amount and calculation formula.
- The current ceiling.
- Any permitted carry-forward or recapture.
- The capped recoverable amount.
- The tenant’s applicable share.
- Estimated payments and the resulting credit or balance.
This is a different exercise from checking your pro-rata percentage. The percentage allocates costs; the cap determines which amount may be allocated under the agreed formula.
Before signing, have a Pennsylvania attorney review the clause and ask the landlord or property manager to demonstrate the calculation. Before paying a reconciliation, compare that calculation with the same worksheet.
The percentage is the headline. The expense definition and formula are the protection.
This article is general education, not legal, accounting or tax advice. Actual obligations depend on the lease and applicable law.
Sources
[1] American Bar Association, “An Introduction to Operating Expenses in Commercial Leases,” January–February 2024. https://www.americanbar.org/groups/real_property_trust_estate/resources/probate-property/2024-january-february/an-introduction-operating-expenses-commercial-leases/
[2] Hirschler, “Strategies for Drafting Caps on Controllable Expenses in Commercial Leases,” April 8, 2026. https://www.hirschlerlaw.com/newsroom-publications-strategies-for-drafting-caps-controllable-expenses
[3] Hollander Real Estate Law, “Tip for Commercial Real Estate Tenants: Negotiating a Cap on Controllable Operating Expenses,” June 19, 2024. https://hollanderpllc.com/2024/06/tip-for-commercial-real-estate-tenants-negotiating-a-cap-on-controllable-operating-expenses/
All sources accessed October 15, 2026.
Sources & further reading
- 1. American Bar Association — operating expenses and cap negotiationJanuary–February 2024; accessed October 15, 2026
- 2. Hirschler — drafting controllable-expense capsPublished April 8, 2026; accessed October 15, 2026
- 3. Hollander Real Estate Law — controllable-expense cap examplePublished June 19, 2024; accessed October 15, 2026
How does this affect your property?
Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.
Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space
Talk with Zach