Learn commercial real estate / Lancaster County and Central Pennsylvania

NNN property taxes: estimates, appeals and reassessment bills

Lancaster County’s reassessment makes it important to define the tax parcel, tenant share, monthly estimate, appeal rights and refund process before the final bill arrives.

In a triple-net lease, real-estate taxes are one of the three expense categories commonly passed through to the tenant. [3] That does not make the tax clause simple.

Lancaster County’s 2027 reassessment makes the details especially important. The county warns that a 2027 assessed value should not be multiplied by the 2026 millage rate because 2027 millage rates will be adjusted. It also says the next opportunity for an annual assessment appeal will be in 2028, with additional information expected in early 2027. [1]

For a tenant or landlord, the practical task is not to predict a tax bill from incomplete numbers. It is to make sure the lease explains how the actual bill will be estimated, allocated, challenged and reconciled.

Reassessment is not the tax bill

Lancaster County says reassessment is intended to place properties at 100 percent of current fair-market value and equalize assessments among properties. The county’s property-owner guide explains that taxing jurisdictions must adjust millage after a countywide reassessment so the reassessment alone does not increase their property-tax revenue. A jurisdiction can later change its rate, but the final bill for a particular property cannot be calculated precisely until the new rates are established. [1][2]

That means two shortcuts should be avoided:

  1. Applying the old millage rate to the new assessed value
  2. Assuming the percentage increase in assessment will equal the percentage increase in taxes

A property can still experience a higher or lower tax bill depending on how its value changed relative to the countywide tax base and what final rates the county, municipality and school district adopt.

Start with the lease’s definition of taxes

A lease should say which charges are included in “real-estate taxes” or “tax expenses.” The definition may include:

  1. County, municipal and school property taxes
  2. Special assessments
  3. Payments in lieu of taxes
  4. Certain taxes imposed as a replacement for property taxes
  5. Costs of a tax appeal
  6. Interest or penalties
  7. Taxes on the landlord’s income, transfer or ownership structure

Those items should not be assumed. The parties can negotiate inclusions and exclusions, and broad lease labels do not replace the actual wording.

Holland and Knight notes that taxes are one of the separate expense categories a tenant commonly pays in a triple-net lease and advises tenants to watch for taxes being duplicated inside the operating-expense definition. [3] A tax should not be collected twice merely because it appears in two defined terms.

Identify the parcel before calculating the share

A tax clause should identify the property against which taxes are allocated. Questions include:

  1. Is the leased building on its own tax parcel?
  2. Does one parcel contain several buildings?
  3. Is vacant land included?
  4. Are future improvements planned on the same parcel?
  5. Does the tenant pay a building share, parcel share or project share?
  6. Can the denominator change if space is added, removed or separately assessed?

This is where the tax clause connects to the pro-rata-share clause. A 10,000-square-foot tenant in a 50,000-square-foot building appears to have a 20 percent share. That answer can change if the lease uses occupied area, rentable area, an entire shopping center, a separate parcel or another agreed denominator.

The lease should also say whether the allocation changes when a parcel is subdivided, combined or reassessed after new construction.

Separate the monthly estimate from the final bill

Many leases collect one-twelfth of the landlord’s estimated annual tax charge each month, then reconcile the estimate after the actual bill is known. A 2026 SEC-filed lease provides one example: the tenant pays its proportionate share based on a landlord estimate in monthly installments. [4]

Consider a hypothetical example:

  1. The property’s prior annual tax bill is $200,000.
  2. The tenant’s agreed share is 20 percent.
  3. The tenant pays an estimated $3,333.33 per month, or approximately $40,000 for the year.
  4. The final annual bill is $230,000.
  5. The tenant’s final share is $46,000.
  6. The reconciliation balance is approximately $6,000.

This is only a lease-math illustration, not a Lancaster County tax forecast. It shows why a tenant can receive a catch-up bill even when every monthly estimate was paid on time.

The lease should state:

  1. When the landlord must deliver the annual estimate
  2. When the reconciliation is due
  3. What records accompany it
  4. How quickly an underpayment must be paid
  5. When an overpayment is credited or refunded
  6. Whether the obligation survives lease expiration
  7. How a partial first or last year is prorated

Decide who controls an appeal

The person paying the tax is not always the person legally entitled to file the appeal. The lease should assign the process.

A filed commercial lease shows how detailed that procedure can become. Its tenant could pursue a tax contest only after the landlord declined, with advance notice, continued payment of taxes, approved advisers and responsibility for costs. [4] That is one negotiated example, not a rule for every Pennsylvania lease.

A practical clause can address:

  1. Who monitors assessment and appeal deadlines
  2. Who decides whether an appeal is economically justified
  3. Whether the tenant may request or initiate an appeal
  4. Required notice to the other party
  5. Who selects the appraiser and counsel
  6. Who pays appeal expenses
  7. Whether taxes must still be paid during the appeal
  8. Who controls settlement
  9. How later tax years are affected
  10. How any refund is divided

Lancaster County currently states that the next annual appeal opportunity will be in 2028. [1] A lease signed now should still assign responsibility for watching that future deadline rather than relying on either party to assume the other is handling it.

Follow the refund back to the payer

If an appeal produces a refund, the lease should explain:

  1. Whether appeal costs are deducted first
  2. Which tenant receives the credit
  3. How the refund is divided if several tenants funded the tax
  4. What happens if the refund arrives after a tenant leaves
  5. Whether interest received from the taxing authority is included
  6. How a refund affecting several tax years is allocated

The same principle applies to supplemental bills. The parties should identify which lease year bears the charge and whether a former tenant remains responsible for a period during which it occupied the premises.

A reassessment-ready tax checklist

Before approving a lease or annual reconciliation, confirm:

  1. The included and excluded tax categories
  2. The exact parcels and improvements covered
  3. The tenant’s numerator and denominator
  4. Treatment of vacancy and future construction
  5. Monthly estimate and reconciliation dates
  6. Supporting bills and allocation worksheet
  7. Audit and objection deadlines
  8. Appeal authority, notice and cost
  9. Refund allocation
  10. Partial-year proration
  11. Treatment after assignment, sublease or expiration
  12. Any duplication with operating expenses

The reassessment changes the assessed values. The lease determines how the resulting bills move between landlord and tenant. A clear tax clause should make that movement traceable from the government bill to the monthly estimate, final reconciliation and any later appeal refund.

This article is general educational information, not legal, tax, appraisal or accounting advice. The lease, assessment record and tax bills should be reviewed for the specific property.

Sources & further reading

How does this affect your property?

Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.

Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space

Talk with Zach