Learn commercial real estate / Lancaster County and Central Pennsylvania

Percentage rent: when does a retail tenant pay more than base rent?

A sales-based rent clause needs more than a percentage. A worked example shows how the breakpoint changes the bill, why sales are not profit and which other occupancy charges still need to be budgeted.

In a retail lease with base rent plus percentage rent, the tenant pays the base amount and an additional charge when qualifying sales exceed an agreed threshold. That threshold is often called the breakpoint. NAIOP’s definition describes this structure as base rent accompanied by a percentage of sales or gross income above a specified amount. [1]

The percentage is only part of the price. The threshold, sales definition and accounting period determine the calculation. Do not assume every sales-based proposal uses the same formula.

A simple annual example

These invented figures illustrate one structure; they are not Lancaster market terms or a recommended rent:

Annual base rent: $48,000.

Percentage rate: 6%.

Annual qualifying sales: $1,000,000.

A natural breakpoint is calculated by dividing annual base rent by the percentage rate: $48,000 ÷ 0.06 = $800,000. ICSC’s retail-leasing materials explain this calculation and distinguish it from another threshold negotiated by the parties. [2]

With that natural breakpoint, sales above the threshold equal $200,000. The extra rent is $200,000 × 6% = $12,000. Base rent plus percentage rent totals $60,000.

Now suppose the agreement instead fixes the threshold at $600,000. The same sales produce $24,000 of extra rent and $72,000 of combined rent. The rate has not changed, but the annual bill is $12,000 higher.

Below either threshold, this example still requires the full $48,000 base rent. Sales-based extra rent does not make the base amount disappear.

Sales are not profit

A store can generate substantial sales while carrying substantial inventory, payroll and other costs. Budgeting should test the rent against cash flow, not treat sales as money available to spend.

The lease also needs an exact sales definition. ICSC discusses negotiated exclusions and the complications of online transactions. [2] Ask how the agreement treats returns, sales taxes, gift cards and orders connected with the store. Have the accounting system and lease language reviewed together.

Percentage rent is not necessarily the whole occupancy bill

An actual historical DSW lease filed with the SEC illustrates the distinction. Its sections 4–5 separately address base rent, percentage rent and estimated contributions toward maintenance, real estate taxes and insurance. [3] That 2006 Virginia agreement is an example of separately stated charges—not a Pennsylvania legal rule or current local pricing.

For the hypothetical natural-breakpoint case above, another $9,000 of annual occupancy charges would bring the illustrated total to $69,000, before any other expenses.

Before signing, request a calculation at low, expected and high sales; confirm whether the threshold changes when base rent rises; and identify reporting and payment dates. An annual budget divided by twelve is not necessarily the payment schedule.

This is general education, not legal or accounting advice. A commercial real estate attorney and accountant should review the actual clause and reporting requirements.

Sources

[1] NAIOP Research Foundation — commercial real estate definitions. 2024 edition, page 16; accessed October 20, 2026. https://www.naiop.org/globalassets/research-and-publications/report/terms-and-definitions-/naiop-2024-terms-and-definitions.pdf

[2] ICSC — Gross Sales Exclusions: What Is a Sale Anyway?. Conference materials dated October 9, 2025; accessed October 20, 2026. https://www.icsc.com/uploads/event_documents/2025LC_Peer_to_Peer_7.pdf

[3] DSW — historical Virginia lease filed with the SEC. Lease dated November 27, 2006, sections 4–5; accessed October 20, 2026. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/874444/000095015206009919/l23542aexv10w2.htm

Sources & further reading

How does this affect your property?

Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.

Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space

Talk with Zach