Retail co-tenancy clauses: define the anchor, occupancy test and remedy
A co-tenancy clause can change opening duties, rent or termination rights when a shopping center’s promised tenant mix is not operating. The protection works only when the lease defines the trigger, proof, cure and remedy precisely.
A retail co-tenancy clause connects one tenant’s lease obligations to the operation of other stores in the same center. It may address whether the tenant must open, whether full rent is due or whether the tenant can terminate if a named anchor closes or overall occupancy falls below an agreed level.
The concept sounds simple. The drafting is not. “The anchor left” does not answer which store counts, how long the vacancy must continue, what evidence is required or what happens next.
Opening and continuing co-tenancy are different
An opening co-tenancy test applies when the tenant is preparing to open. It might require a named anchor, a minimum percentage of gross leasable area or a particular mix of stores to be open and operating.
A continuing co-tenancy test applies after the tenant has opened. It asks whether the required tenant mix or occupancy level remains in place during the lease term.
ICSC materials explain that co-tenancy remedies often include delayed opening, reduced or alternative rent and, after a stated period, a termination right. They also emphasize that the requirement, measurement and remedy need objective definitions. [1]
A landlord may resist broad protection because the departure of another tenant is not always within the landlord’s immediate control. A tenant may argue that the surrounding mix was part of the reason it selected and priced the location. The signed clause determines how that risk is divided.
Define the trigger with property-level detail
A useful review should answer at least these questions:
- Is the test based on named tenants, occupied area, open stores or a combination?
- What exactly is the shopping center included in the calculation?
- Does gross leasable area exclude the tenant’s own premises, kiosks, offices, restaurants or vacant redevelopment space?
- Must a named anchor be open, fully operating and using a stated minimum area?
- Can a comparable replacement satisfy the requirement?
- How is a comparable replacement defined?
- Does a temporary closure for remodeling, casualty or seasonal hours count?
- Is there a grace or cure period?
- Must the tenant remain open and free of default to use the remedy?
- Who verifies the occupancy calculation?
A percentage without a clear numerator and denominator is not a complete occupancy test.
An actual lease shows how specific the language can become
A 2011 Hibbett Sporting Goods lease filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission is a historical Alabama example, not a Pennsylvania rule or a statement of current Lancaster deal terms. It named Books-A-Million and Publix as opening co-tenants, described their minimum areas and operating conditions, and provided an alternative percentage-of-sales rent if the opening requirement was not met. [2]
The same lease also addressed continuing co-tenancy, defined a comparable replacement using store count, geography, customer profile and square footage, required occupancy notices and gave the tenant an audit right. [2]
The useful lesson is not to copy that agreement. It is to see how many decisions sit behind one short term-sheet phrase. “Co-tenancy protection” can refer to very different economic rights depending on the named stores, area test, substitute standard, duration and proof.
A simple alternative-rent example
Assume a retailer’s regular monthly base rent is $8,000. The negotiated co-tenancy remedy changes rent to 5 percent of monthly gross sales while the trigger remains unsatisfied, capped at the normal base rent.
If monthly gross sales are $90,000:
$90,000 × 5 percent = $4,500.
The illustrated base-rent reduction would be $3,500 for that month.
If monthly gross sales are $180,000:
$180,000 × 5 percent = $9,000.
Because this hypothetical formula caps alternative rent at the regular $8,000 base rent, the tenant would pay $8,000.
A different lease could use half of minimum rent, a different sales percentage, no cap, or a remedy that affects additional rent as well as base rent. The formula must say which charges change, when the change begins and when full rent resumes.
KPMG’s lease handbook notes that co-tenancy clauses can convert fixed rent into a sales-based payment for a stated period or until the condition is cured. It also warns that the trigger can create accounting consequences for both tenant and landlord. [3] The operating team, attorney and accountant should read the same final language.
Proof and timing matter as much as the formula
A tenant cannot apply a remedy reliably if it cannot determine whether the condition failed. ICSC recommends addressing landlord certification, supporting documentation, notice when the failure is cured and tenant audit rights. [1]
The lease should also identify:
- Who sends the first notice
- Whether reduced rent is automatic or requires an election
- Whether relief begins on the failure date or notice date
- How overpayments are credited
- How long alternative rent may continue
- When the tenant must choose between full rent and termination
- Whether a last-minute cure can stop a pending termination
- What records support the occupancy and sales calculations
A calendar should track every notice, cure and election deadline. Missing one deadline can change the practical value of the clause.
Co-tenancy is one part of the site decision
A busy anchor can support customer traffic, but no lease clause guarantees sales. Access, visibility, signs, parking, customer demographics, tenant mix, competition and the retailer’s own execution still matter.
For Lancaster retail tenants, the practical goal is to identify which surrounding conditions are important enough to affect the deal and then define them objectively. For landlords, the goal is to understand the combined exposure created when several leases depend on the same anchor or occupancy threshold.
This is general educational information, not legal or accounting advice. Pennsylvania counsel and the parties’ accountants should review the actual lease and financial treatment.
Sources & further reading
How does this affect your property?
Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.
Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space
Talk with Zach