New Businesses / East Lampeter Township, Lancaster County, Pennsylvania

Toys R Us plans a 6,000-square-foot store at Tanger Lancaster

The smaller-format Toys R Us is planned before Thanksgiving, not yet reported open. The useful property lesson is how a curated holiday shop uses an established retail center.

Toys R Us is planning a return to Lancaster County in a much smaller format than the big-box store many shoppers remember.

Local reporting on November 4 says a 6,000-square-foot store is slated to open at Tanger Outlets Lancaster before Thanksgiving, between Michael Kors and Sunglass Hut. The store was not yet reported open on November 4. [1]

Earlier reporting from WHTM confirmed Tanger’s announcement that the retailer was coming for the holiday period, but at that point no specific opening date had been given. [2] The status should therefore remain “planned” until Tanger or Toys R Us posts a live store listing or opening notice.

The local store is part of a national rollout

Toys R Us announced on September 17 that it was working with Go! Retail Group to open 120 standalone U.S. stores during the 2026 holiday season. The company said the rollout would bring its standalone U.S. count to 160 and would use curated assortments rather than the inventory depth associated with its former big boxes. [3]

Tanger’s corporate property page lists the Lancaster center at 377,000 square feet along the Route 30 and Lincoln Highway East corridor. [4] A 6,000-square-foot shop is only about 1.6 percent of that gross leasable area.

That comparison matters because this is not a return to the old format. It is a small shop inside an established retail destination.

Small format changes the property job

A 6,000-square-foot toy store cannot perform like a 40,000-square-foot or 50,000-square-foot category killer. It has to make sharper decisions about assortment, replenishment and customer flow.

For a retailer using a similar format, the test fit should identify:

  1. The sales-floor area after stockroom, office and receiving space are removed.
  2. Delivery frequency and the route from truck to stockroom.
  3. Display fixtures that can change between seasonal merchandise sets.
  4. Queue space during peak weekends.
  5. Visibility from the primary pedestrian path and parking fields.
  6. Sign rights, holiday graphics and any temporary display rules.
  7. The process for returns, online orders and out-of-stock items.

The smaller footprint can reduce occupancy and buildout exposure, but it also leaves less room for slow-moving inventory or an inefficient back-of-house plan.

“Pop-up” and “year-round” are not the same lease

Published reports currently use different descriptions of the store’s expected duration. WPMT called it a pop-up, while LancasterOnline reporting summarized by Today in Lancaster said it would remain beyond the holiday season. [1]

That difference should not be resolved by guessing. For property owners and tenants, it illustrates why a short-term retail deal needs four dates in writing:

  1. Possession date.
  2. Required opening date.
  3. Last day of required operations.
  4. Surrender date, including removal and restoration work.

A store can stay beyond December and still be governed by a shorter or more flexible agreement than a conventional long-term lease.

What the opening can tell other Lancaster retailers

The announcement is a positive addition to Tanger’s tenant mix and gives Lancaster shoppers another toy destination. It is not evidence that every small retail space will work for a seasonal concept.

The transferable lesson is the match between a curated retailer and an established center. Tanger supplies a known shopping destination and regional access. Toys R Us supplies a recognizable brand and a concentrated holiday assortment. The store still has to execute inventory, staffing and opening timing within a compact footprint.

For another retailer considering a holiday shop, the useful comparison is not simply rent per square foot. It is total occupancy cost divided by the realistic sales window, with buildout, fixtures, freight, staffing, restoration and unsold inventory included.

Sources & further reading

How does this affect your property?

Bring your questions about buying, leasing or owning commercial space.

Find business space · Sell or lease a property · Industrial and flex space

Talk with Zach